Sci fi, fantasy, weird and big freakin' squid


October 12, 2009

Shlocky Holmes and the Case of the Dunderheads

More articles by »
Written by: Kat Clay
Tags: , , , ,

I’ve been going through a Victoriana bingefest lately – Wilkie Collins, Bram Stoker, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen…

So I thought I’d hark back to the world’s number one detective, the marvellously arrogant Sherlock Holmes. The famous detective was created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and was first published in 1887, appearing in more than fifty stories up until 1914. His death caused such an uproar that the circulation of the Strand magazine dropped by 20, 000 readers. Never before has a fictional character had such an influence on society and the development of detection.

I just finished reading A Study in Scarlet, Mr Holmes’ first adventure, in which he meets Mr Watson and embarks on an investigation of an apparently unsolvable murder, where the words RAICHE have been written on the wall in blood. Sherlock outwits not only the criminals but also Inspector Lestrade’s bumbling investigations that go in all the wrong directions. I had never realised how much fun Sherlock Holmes is. The delight in following Holmes solve mysteries is partly due to his snobbish arrogance, his bad violin playing and the use of words like ‘dunderheads’ to describe the bumbling Scotland Yarders that can’t grasp his higher intellect.

A Study in Scarlet was the first Sherlock Holmes story

A Study in Scarlet was the first Sherlock Holmes story

I must admit, I too was perplexed by some of the Holmesian logic. Conan Doyle does a great job of explaining this away by simply writing that it would take too long to explain the logic and by that time the bad guy would have got away. I personally can’t wait to encounter that notorious nasty of the nineteen hundreds, Professor Moriaty. Because in this first installment, it all seems a little too easy for Holmes; I can understand why he would need to meet his equal.

The stories read well, even a hundred years after their conception. It’s easy to see the impact that a fictional character has had on the real world; his process of methodical deduction influenced today’s forensic science. Those guys on CSI owe their jobs to the consulting detective. The tales have hugely influenced the way detective stories are written, assuring us that an interesting character can be just as compelling as crime.

There’s a new movie coming out, and despite the fact that it’s directed by Guy Ritchie, one of the most overrated directors of all time (I don’t care if you liked Lock Stock, I fell asleep in it), it does have fantastic casting, featuring Robert Downey Jr. as said detective. Not so sure about Jude Law as Watson but I guess that’s to get the ladies in. I always thought of him as a pudgy guy with a handlebar moustache. Mmmm… Jude Law with a handlebar moustache. Nevermind. Go and read the original instead.

About the Author

Kat Clay
Kat Clay loves fiction, travelling and giant squid. She is trained in fencing, speaks five languages and is being considered as the next Bond villain.



Interview with Kevin J Anderson

Kevin J Anderson is the author of over 115 novels, 50 of which have been bestsellers. His work has been translated into 30 languages and he has well over 23 million books in print. I interviewed him about the recent re-release ...
by Kat Clay


Earthsea: an exercise in humility

I look at the classic fantasy series Earthsea by Ursula K Le Guin
by Kat Clay


Weird Fiction News Flash

There’s been a few bits and pieces on the weird fiction radar lately and since I’ve been doing a lot on video games I thought I better get back to my books. So here goes: Cthullu’s News Desk at nine. Jeff Vandermeer a...
by Kat Clay



World fantasy awards, draft swapping and Margo Lanagan

On the weekend I attended a draft swap meeting run by a dear friend of mine, Jan Cornall. Jan’s a great facilitator, she’s led a number of wonderful authors from first concept to publication, one of them being the award-win...
by Kat Clay


Dead, dead, dead: Charlaine Harris and the Southern Vampire Mysteries

How much do you blood me? Kat gets into the Sookie Stackhouse mysteries, written by Charlaine Harris.
by Kat Clay



  1. Lock, Stock was great, although it did suffer from the samy-ness of several of the characters. Snatch fixed that, and is one of the great crime caper movies, in my opinion. True, Ritchie hasn’t done a lot since then (Swept Away is reportedly one of the worst films ever), but I don’t see how Downey Jr as Holmes can be anything but the most awesome thing ever.

    Oh, and “Dunderhead” is one of my Dad’s most common expressions.

  2. Kat

    Yeah Snatch was the most enjoyable (read: I didn’t fall asleep in it). I would really like to watch Swept Away for the crap factor. And I thought Gigli is meant to be the crappest movie ever?

    Also your dad is cool!! Dunderheads is a great word and I totally endorse his use of it.

  3. Jude Law could win the oscar award for best actor.~-:

Leave a Reply